Host makes friend pay $250 for antique heirloom chair that broke under her, friend says no: 'It broke from your weight plopping down all at once'

Author image for JR Atkinson
JR Atkinson • Writer and Editor
Sep 3, 2025 10:00 PM EDT

The embarrassment of breaking something at someone's house is payment enough in my book. Who in their right mind wouldn't feel crazy if they broke something? Most people have more than a healthy amount of shame in them; they don't need any extra. If I broke a glass at someone's house, I would feel so ashamed that to ask for payment on top of that would be like gilding the lily. 

I heard an anecdote once about a hostess who took her job so seriously that she would purposefully break one of her plates in front of everyone to show that it was okay so that her guests could carry on without fear of breaking something. If the host is endorsing it, it must be okay. I find this to be a very powerful story. The sacrifice of a host to give up something she presumably cares about to allow her guests the freedom of a good time unmarred by the fear of breaking something. This is how all hosts should be, because when you take on the job, you take on the risk that something you love will break. 

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • A woman sits sideways on a yellow chair.
    via Laura Chouette

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • The best motto remains: be a mensch. If someone unintentionally breaks something in your house, refuse their offer to pay for it. It's your house, and your job was to make everyone feel comfortable, and you should do your best to move on. But that's not what happened in this story, unfortunately. Read on for the details. 

  • AITA for refusing to reimburse my friend for a chair that broke under me?

    I (F25) was at a friend's house for a game night this past weekend with a group of about 6. Everyone brought food and drinks and we were having a good time, when about halfway through the night I got up to use the bathroom. When I came back, I saw that one of the girls had moved from a chair to the side to my space on the
    via u/FiguringItOutThisWay
  • couch. This didn't bug me as people shuffle around in groups, so whatever. The chair was an antique wooden chair that sat a bit lower to the ground with an added back/bot cushion. When I sat down it immediately broke, sending me to the ground with the seat under me and the arm frames falling to the side.
    via u/FiguringItOutThisWay
  • Everyone got quiet for a second before jumping up to help me. I wasn't hurt, just very embarrassed. For context I'm a bigger girl, about 260 pounds at 5 foot 7 inches. My friend (F27) was very gracious and nice about it when it happened, accepting my apologies and telling me not to worry. Her boyfriend (M29) said that the chair was his grandmother's and it has fallen apart before and he was able to repair it. I was ushered back to the couch and game night continued.
    via u/FiguringItOutThisWay
  • Fast forward to the next morning, I received a text from my friend who let me know that the chair couldn't be put back together, and that from her research it would cost about $250 to get a new one, but she'd let me know exactly how much when she found one. I was a bit taken aback, and responded confused,
    via u/FiguringItOutThisWay
  • asking why I would be expected to pay for a faulty chair. She said that while yes, on occasion the frames would become unattached and cause it to fall apart, but that that's not what happened this time. She sent me pictures of the broken chair, particularly a bent support and 2 other broken supports. She said that the chair broke under my weight and couldn't be fixed, and since the chair was an antique from her boyfriend's late grandmother, she wanted a new one for him.
    via u/FiguringItOutThisWay
  • I responded that the chair was very old and had a history of collapsing. If they were concerned about preserving it, they should've not had it out for people to use, and $250+ for a chair I sat in for 1 second seems a bit ridiculous. At this point she seemingly got frustrated, and said that she loves me but that I'm her
    via u/FiguringItOutThisWay
  • "biggest friend" and that it wouldn't have happened to anyone else. She said: "It broke from your weight plopping down all at once, not because the frame was loose. I think it's only fair you reimburse us for the chair since you're responsible for breaking it."
    via u/FiguringItOutThisWay
  • I'm still figuring out how to respond. I don't want to pay her for something I don't see as being completely my fault. I also think she's using the scenario to shame me about my weight a bit, which I find frustrating. My friends' opinions are mixed. A few are saying that I should just pay her and move on, even if it's not exactly my fault. One thinks it is my fault and I should pay up, and a few more think she's in the wrong for asking and I should continue to politely decline. AITA for refusing
    via u/FiguringItOutThisWay
  • Old antique chairs shine in the light.
    via Xiangkun ZHU

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • Commenters had varying opinions on what to do in this scenario.

    • Big_Bookkeeper1678 17h ago The person who moved from the chair to the couch broke it... You were the 'fall guy', literally. Do NOT pay. These people are using you to replace a chair that was already broken.
    via u/Big_Bookkeeper1678
  • catsaway9 18h ago If I broke something at a friend's house, I'd offer to pay for it. If a friend broke something at my house, I'd decline their offer to pay.
    via u/catsaway9
  • I'm not sure which is correct, so I'm not passing judgement on who's TA. I agree that they shouldn't have had it out where people could sit on it, especially since it had both sentimental and intrinsic value, and was not in good repair.
    via u/catsaway9
  • • BelowXpectations · 17h ago NTA • Don't let people door on a chair of it's that important. You can't buy a new chair with sentimental value. Repair or give up. • A chair that has broken several times already is just an accident waiting to happen.
    via u/BelowXpectations
  • • You don't leave a frequentöy broken chair out to sit on. • You can't charge for sentimental value I'm sorry but your friend... isn't your friend.
    via u/BelowXpectations
  • BustAMove_13 · 17h ago • NTA. Also, this is his chair from his Gran. That's why it means something, so how is replacing it going to work? A replacement won't have any meaning to him.
    via u/BustAMove_13
  • non_... . • 17h ago Edited 14h ago Light ESH. I'm a big dude. As in potentially breaking chairs big. Not trying to be ride here, but you should really be cognizant of your weight when you go to sit places, especially at friends' houses.
    via u/non_clever_username
  • Most of the time, you can tell by looking if a chair is well-made, but even if not, it's not that hard to lightly put your partial weight on a chair if it looks questionable. It's pretty easy to tell if it might not support you when putting your partial weight on it. I get that it's kind of embarrassing to have to ask for a different chair if you find a questionable one, but it's exponentially less embarrassing than breaking it.
    via u/non_clever_username
  • Closer to Y T A if you did actually plop down with your full weight on it instead of carefully sitting down; that's not very cool. It's not rode or fat- shaming IMO to expect you to be aware that your weight could have adverse impacts on other people or their stuff.
    via u/non_clever_username
  • That said, as you say, your friend is being kind of too. You don't put out a chair for guests that's already broken a couple times and then ask a friend to pay for it when it does actually break. If this person was really your friend, she would have not said anything, knowing you were already embarrassed, and made a note to have a sturdier chair around for you in the future.
    via u/non_clever_username
  • E: and for that matter I agree with others that this whole thing seems a little sus. If it is truly an antique, what good is replacing it?
    via u/non_clever_username
  • mvms 18h ago • I am also a bigger person. I would in no circumstances sit in an antique chair. They are almost always fragile. YTA, I'm afraid.
    via u/mvms
  • . Appropriate_Sky_7676 17h ago She shouldn't be putting out an heirloom antique chair for anyone to sit on. You could actually fake a back injury and say geez you let me sit in a chair that was too fragile and I hurt my back when I fell. How about paying for the doctor bills?. I wonder what she would say to that?
    via u/Appropriate_Sky_7676
  • angels-and-insects · 17h ago NTA. I wouldn't dream of charging a friend for a chair that broke under them. And while 250lb (113kg for us metric folk) is heavy, it shouldn't be chair- breaking heavy. Overweight men supercede that easily. H I, a light adult putting a child on their lap would supercede that. Your friend is extremely ride. Delicate antique chairs should be put to the side, not set out at dinner parties.
    via u/angels-and-insects
  • JoeLefty500 18h ago It's not your fault at all. By her own admission, the chair has broken in the past and it's very old. Tell her you're having neck and back pain from the fall and that you're considering getting a lawyer. This friendship is toast whatever happens. Don't pay anything.
    via u/JoeLefty500
  • TheGoodDoc123 17h ago YTA. I'm sorry, but when you're 260 pounds, you should know better than to sit on an old antiquey-looking wooden chair. Just because they had the chair out in the open, doesn't absolve you of using common sense of whether it can support your weight.
    via u/TheGoodDoc123
  • As for the friend, consider it isn't even her chair. It's her boyfriend's. She probably feels responsible that one of her friends came over to his house and ruined his grandma's furniture. I know I'd feel that way if I were her. My guess is she'll reimburse him whether OP pays up or not, since that's the decent thing to do. OP should do the decent thing too.
    via u/TheGoodDoc123
  • Conscious-Shoulder14 17h ago • Normally, I feel like if you break something at someone else's house, you are responsible for replacing it. However, in this case, they knew it had a history of breaking and still provided it for you to use, also knowing that you are the heaviest member of the group. I don't think you owe them a dime.
    via u/Conscious-Shoulder14

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

friendship relationship advice aita drama weight AITAH best friends hosting storytime friends listen to your friends reddit story relationships friend drama friend shame story reddit thread Reddit discourse conflict
Scroll Down For The Next Article